If it's considered that suffering is incompatible with some higher purpose to our existence, then what would the world have to be like so that it is compatible with some higher purpose? Perhaps if no one ever experienced any pain; not just physical but mental pain too? And no one ever experienced misery, least of all depression? Indeed, that our lives are in a constant state of maximum happiness?
And what would such happiness consist in? Pleasures? Or the feeling like you had as a child when you woke up on a Christmas day morning? Or if you were in a permanent state of a certain type of intellectual satisfaction?
Obviously that's silly. But perhaps people mean there's too much suffering -- not that we shouldn't have any suffering at all. But how do we work out how much suffering would be compatible with some higher purpose?
I think arguably suffering, pain, anguish, despair, loss of a loved one etc, could conceivably be held to be compatible with some higher purpose. For much of history, mankind lived a life full of dangers with the constant threat of death, and suffering, and loss. Close brushes with death from predators with the consequent comradeship and camaraderie when others save your life, and you theirs. The collective outpouring of emotions, the bitter and sweet taste of life in the raw.
In the modern west we are cosseted from all the harsh elements of life. I'll probably die an old man rather than get eaten by a predator. But perhaps, safe and rich as we are, the modern western way of life loses something. It loses the sheer rapture of being alive. If we never experience any dangers, then the sheer thrill of having overcome dangers is also lacking.
So it's not clear to me that suffering is necessarily incompatible with some higher purpose. The problem here is we don't know what the purpose of life is! Hence I think it's impossible to answer such a question.
Maybe it is, but until we know what the purpose of life is, why we are here, how can we say what the nature of our lives should be like?
Mostly philosophical topics, especially pertaining to the philosophy of mind and whether an afterlife makes sense.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Ralph Lewis's Arguments against an Afterlife
I read an article by Ralph Lewis M.D entitled: Is There Life After Death? The Mind-Body Problem He attacks any possibility of an afterlife....
Popular Posts
-
Note: This response is approximately 13,000 words long. I have a shorter version of approximately 5,000 words that I have called A Review ...
-
1. Preliminary I recently finished reading The Soul Fallacy by Julien Musolino for the second time, and I thought I'd pen down some of...
-
1. Introduction Common sense holds that what has been labelled the secondary qualities , such as colours, sounds and odours, exist out there...
-
Steven Novella , an American clinical neurologist, is well-known in the skeptical community and is co-founder of the New England Skeptical S...
-
People ask what's the point of life, what's the point of the Universe, and even if there's an afterlife, what would be the point...
-
1. Introduction I read this article a couple of weeks ago by a professor of philosophy called John G Messerly. He says: There has b...
-
There's a new AI chatbot called ChatGPT that seems to be vastly superior in its responses to any other chatbot I have attempted to con...
-
Introduction: I read the following article: Why Parapsychological Claims Cannot Be True It says: The entire field [of parapsychol...
-
I read an article by Ralph Lewis M.D entitled: Is There Life After Death? The Mind-Body Problem He attacks any possibility of an afterlife....
-
Preamble The rally, or the last hurrah, which in recent years has been termed terminal lucidity , refers to where a person, typically suffer...
I see no point to life. What's to like about being a 9 to 5 slave every day in some crappy job just to keep a roof over my head while I gradually turn into some old wrinkly man? I wish I'd been consulted before being brought into this world as there's no way I would have agreed to this crap.
ReplyDeleteYes, you might find 2 blog entries in my other blog relevant here:
Deletehttp://ianwardells.blogspot.co.uk/2016/06/that-which-is-inimical-to-our-yearning.html
http://ianwardells.blogspot.co.uk/2016/08/are-you-slave-to-system.html
I think perhaps the only realistic option is to somehow become self-employed.
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2013/04/16/if-youre-going-to-quit-a-9-to-5-job-that-doesnt-make-you-happy-this-is-the-way-to-do-it/
In a recent interview a woman reveals the meaning of life shown to her after an absolutely real shamanism experience around 8:03
ReplyDeletehttps://www.cbsnews.com/video/psychedelic-drugs-lsd-active-agent-in-magic-mushrooms-to-treat-addiction-depression-anxiety-60-minutes-2019-12-29/