Wednesday, 10 November 2021

Bigelow competition for the best essay on the evidence for an afterlife

The results of this competition have recently been announced.  Go here.  Apparently all 29 essays that won a prize will shortly be freely available to read.  I'd just like to make a few comments.

By far the main obstacle to an acceptance of an afterlife is the notion held by the intelligentsia that an afterlife is an "extraordinary claim". Any evidence, no matter how persuasive, is typically simply written off as not being extraordinary enough. This being so, simply outlining the evidence in its various forms will be insufficient if we hope to convince skeptics, particularly so for those of an academic persuasion. The question of why an afterlife is considered to be an extraordinary claim needs to be addressed and rebutted. This involves underlying philosophical issues
(e.g. does the fact damaged brains lead to damaged minds entail the former produces the latter as many skeptics allege?).  Unfortunately, since the competition explicitly asked for the best evidence, I fear none of these essays will devote much space to such issues (the explicit emphasis on evidence is the reason why I didn't submit an essay to the competition myself).

It would have been far better if the competition were open to any essays that persuasively argue that the survival (afterlife) hypothesis is a reasonable one and, furthermore, more reasonable than the annihilation hypothesis. The essays could then have had the option of either simply addressing the evidence, addressing the underlying philosophical issues, or ideally, addressing both. Then the essays, as a collective whole, would be more likely to present a more rounded and robust appraisal of the various reasons to regard the belief in an afterlife as being a reasonable one.

The problem with all the pro-afterlife material that currently exists is that the vast majority of it doesn't touch the philosophical issues and this competition simply perpetuates this imbalance.  My suspicion is that most of these essays will largely regurgitate the evidence that is already out there and will do little to persuade skeptics.  But we shall see.

5 comments:

  1. Will you provide the link for the essays when they are made available please? Thank you, --Wm. Francis Brown MD, Camden, Maine

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, hopefully I'll remember.

      Delete
    2. Here is the link to all essays to download:

      https://www.bigelowinstitute.org/contest_winners3.php?fbclid=IwAR0z0meu76ruGkicl7A0qsY8OYd6G-teuM7ijuTch-CNT38o2WmUvfrzzv8

      Also, I've commented on the winning essay.


      https://ian-wardell.blogspot.com/2021/11/thoughts-on-winning-bics-essay.html

      Delete
  2. I think if there's another contest you should enter anyway, make this point and wax philosophical (& compelling) for 25K words.

    ReplyDelete
  3. https://www.nonlocalmind.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Jeff-Mishlove-Essay-for-Bigelow-Institute.pdf this is a link to the 1st place essay found this on the Daily grail.

    ReplyDelete

Comments must relate to the blog post or they will not be published.

Why are people so certain there's no soul or an afterlife?

Are we essentially souls and will our souls continue on after we die? Both from a philosophical perspective and by virtue of all the evidenc...

Popular Posts